Links from other websites remain one of the strongest signals in search. A business that has been trading for years has usually earned a good number of them without ever asking: a local paper covering an opening, a blog citing a useful guide, a directory listing a branch.

Those links point at specific addresses on your site. When an address stops working, the link still exists, but it now points at an error page, and the value it carried goes nowhere.

What we found

On one live account with around 1,800 linking websites, at least 106 of them pointed at photo files on the site that now returned an error. The files had been moved or deleted during routine site changes. Nobody had noticed, because nothing on the site itself looked broken.

Over the same sixty days, the site discovered 50 new linking websites and lost 93. The net position was minus forty-three linking websites in two months. Some of that is normal churn. A good part was self-inflicted.

The links in question had not been bought. Most had been earned by genuinely useful content, practical guides that other sites cited because they helped their readers. They were mostly from low-spam sources, with plain anchors such as web addresses and article titles rather than stuffed keywords. That is exactly the kind of link that is hard to get again.

Earning a new link of that quality takes content, time and luck. Recovering an existing one takes a redirect.

The fix

  1. Pull the list of broken targets from a backlink tool (Moz, Ahrefs, Semrush and others all report linking pages that hit an error on your site). Start with the most-linked URLs.
  2. Redirect each dead address to its most relevant live page with a permanent (301) redirect. For a photo of a branch, that is the branch page. For a deleted guide, it is the closest current guide.
  3. Restore the file instead where it is still useful, for example an image that other sites embedded.
  4. Check each redirect resolves in one hop.
  5. Repeat monthly. Sites keep changing, and the next batch of broken links is already forming.

For a multi-location business there is a bonus: many of the lost links point at branch-specific material, so redirecting them to the right branch page strengthens that branch in particular, not just the site in general.

Founder-led practice · geo.bz

See where you stand — free

A free assessment shows exactly where your brand stands across ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Gemini and Google AI Overviews — and what you could build yourself, for free, with the self-hosted βWave™ stack. Compare and contrast before you spend a penny.

Get the free assessment →