Every multi-location business accumulates pages. A campaign needs a landing page. A branch moves and gets a new page while the old one stays up. A site rebuild changes the URL pattern, and nobody redirects the last one. Each decision is reasonable on the day. Added together over years, they produce a site with more addresses than branches.
On one live account we found two and a half times as many location addresses online as the business had branches. Nobody had planned it. It was the residue of campaigns and rebuilds.
Why it matters
Google is trying to answer a simple question for each town: which page represents this branch? When there are two or three candidates, it has to guess, and it does not always guess the page you want.
On that account, a leftover campaign page was still being returned ahead of the real branch page for its town, holding 8,688 impressions of its own. It was already on a list of pages to redirect. It just had not been done.
The cost is not only confusion. Each duplicate page holds a share of the standing the branch has earned: the links pointing at it, the clicks it has collected, the history Google associates with it. Split across three pages, that standing is weaker than it would be on one.
The fix that goes wrong
The instinct is to tidy up by removing the duplicates from Google, either by deleting them or by marking them noindex. That removes the confusion, but it also throws the standing away.
On the same account, seventeen duplicate pages holding 61,900 impressions were set to noindex rather than redirected. The pages disappeared from Google and took everything they had accumulated with them. Same intention, opposite outcome.
The fix that works
- List every URL that represents a branch, including old campaign pages, pages from previous site versions, and anything with a town name in the address.
- Choose one destination per branch. Usually it is the current branch page, but check first. If an older URL is the one Google and other sites actually rate, it may be the better one to keep.
- Redirect every other URL to that destination with a permanent (301) redirect, in a single hop. No chains, no loops.
- Test each redirect after it goes live, from outside your own network, not just in the redirect plugin’s settings screen.
- Re-check in four to six weeks that Google now returns the destination page for the branch’s searches.
A redirect moves the standing across. Removal deletes it. For a branch page, that difference is the whole job.
How to tell if you have the problem
Search your own site with site:yourdomain.co.uk plus a branch town, and count how many different pages come back claiming to be that branch. If it is more than one, every one of the extras is splitting demand that should be arriving in one place.
See where you stand — free
A free assessment shows exactly where your brand stands across ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Gemini and Google AI Overviews — and what you could build yourself, for free, with the self-hosted βWave™ stack. Compare and contrast before you spend a penny.
Get the free assessment →